Financial Planning / Retirement Planning

Is the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) a Good Pension Plan?

The Canada Pension Plan (CPP) is a government-run program that helps Canadians save for retirement. It is designed to replace a portion of your income when you retire, become disabled, or pass away, providing financial security for you and your family. CPP is funded by contributions from both employers and employees, which are invested to provide long-term benefits.

What Makes CPP Unique?

CPP stands out from other retirement savings options because it’s an inflation-indexed annuity. This means the payments you receive from CPP are adjusted for inflation, ensuring your money retains its value over time. This feature is essential as it helps protect retirees from three major risks:

  1. Longevity Risk: This is the risk of outliving your savings. As people live longer, their savings might run out. CPP helps by pooling resources from many people, so those who live longer benefit from the contributions of those who pass away earlier.
  2. Inflation Risk: Inflation decreases the purchasing power of money over time. While stocks and bonds might offer returns that outpace inflation, they don’t provide a guaranteed hedge against it. CPP, however, adjusts payments each year based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI), protecting your retirement income from losing value.
  3. Sequence of Returns Risk: This is the risk of withdrawing from your investments during a period of poor market returns, which can significantly deplete your savings. The guaranteed income from CPP provides a stable financial foundation, regardless of market conditions.

Practical Example: How CPP Can Work for You

Let’s consider two scenarios to better understand how CPP can benefit you:

  • Scenario 1: Typical Lifespan
    Sarah starts contributing to CPP at age 26 and continues until she retires at 65. She begins receiving CPP benefits immediately upon retirement. Sarah’s benefits are adjusted each year for inflation, providing her with a reliable source of income throughout her retirement.
  • Scenario 2: Longer Lifespan with Deferred Benefits
    John, on the other hand, decides to defer his CPP benefits until age 70 to receive a higher payout. He ends up living until 95. By deferring his benefits, John significantly increases his overall CPP income, which provides him greater financial security in his later years.

How Are CPP Contributions Managed?

Contributions to CPP are set to increase by 2025, with both employees and employers contributing up to a combined total of $8,848. These contributions are invested by CPP Investments, a Crown corporation that manages the funds. The investment strategy focuses on long-term, often illiquid assets that individual investors may find difficult to access. This approach has proven successful in managing the fund’s long-term liabilities.

Is CPP Worth It?

Many people might think they can do better with private savings or investments, but this often overlooks the unique benefits that CPP offers. While the internal rate of return (IRR) on CPP contributions might seem modest (around 2% when considering inflation), it increases significantly if you live longer or defer your benefits. For instance, deferring benefits to age 70 and living to age 95 could result in an IRR of 3.11%.

Moreover, CPP’s inflation protection and longevity risk management make it a valuable part of a well-rounded retirement plan. It allows you to take more risks with other investments, potentially increasing your overall returns without risking financial security.

Addressing Common Misconceptions

It’s common for people to believe they could achieve better returns with private investments. However, this perspective often overlooks the unique advantages that CPP offers, particularly its protection against inflation and longevity risk. While private investments are an important part of a retirement strategy, they may not provide the same guaranteed security that CPP offers.

Final Thoughts

The Canada Pension Plan (CPP) is the only inflation-indexed annuity available to most Canadians. It offers protection against some of the biggest risks retirees face, and it does so in ways that individual investors cannot easily replicate. Instead of worrying about CPP’s cost, it’s more productive to plan on how to maximize its benefits for your retirement.


Ready to Maximize Your Retirement?

If you’re planning for retirement and want to ensure you’re making the most of your Canada Pension Plan (CPP) benefits, I invite you to book a meeting with me. Together, we can create a personalized strategy to secure your financial future.

Also, don’t forget to check out my book, The Art of Retirement, for more in-depth insights and strategies to make the most out of your retirement years.

Leave a Comment

The supporting material, audio and video recordings and all information related to the artofretirement websites are designed to educate and provide general information regarding financial planning and all other subject matter covered. It is marketed and distributed with the understanding that the authors and the publishers are not engaged in rendering legal, financial, or other professional advice. It is also understood that laws and practices may vary from province to province and are subject to change. All illustrations provided in these materials are for educational purposes only and individual results will vary. Each illustration provided is unique to that individual and your personal results may vary. Because each factual situation is different, specific advice should be tailored to each individual’s particular circumstances. For this reason, the reader is advised to consult with qualified licensed professionals of their choosing, regarding that individual’s specific situation. The authors have taken reasonable precautions in the preparation of all materials and believe the facts presented are accurate as of the date it was written. However, neither the author nor the publishers assume any responsibility for any errors or omissions. The authors and publisher specifically disclaim any liability resulting from the use or application of the information contained in all materials, and the information is neither intended nor should be relied upon as legal, financial or any other advice related to individual situations.
Mutual funds are provided through Carte Wealth Management Inc. Insurance & segregated funds are provided through Carte Risk Management Inc.